TheRetroArcade
Veteran
Posts: 9,659
Joined: Feb 2026
Joined: Feb 2026
'Pushing back actually worked.'
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.
With the memory crisis only continuing to get worse, a PC gamer's fear right now is likely their memory, storage or GPU borking, and needing to spend an inflated price to replace it. One such Redditor had an external drive die in just one year, and Crucial only offered a refund of the original price they paid, which was a lot less than similar drives go for now. That was until they brought their problems to Reddit.
Over on the PCMR subreddit, user CarefulMeasurement99 shared that they bought a 4 TB Crucial drive a year ago for $200, and when it broke, Crucial offered that original price in a refund. That same drive seems to fetch up to $800 now (thanks, AI).
Crucial originally set up an RMA for the drive in order to pick it up and send it back to the company. The Redditor replied to this saying, "Due to the recent global increase in SSD prices, $199.999 is unfortunately no longer enough to purchase a new 4 TB drive in the current market", and officially requested a direct replacement.
This story gets a tad complicated because Micron announced the closure of the Crucial consumer business late last year, which threw its ability to actually replace the drive into question.
Crucial responded to this request saying, "after reviewing the current inventory situation, we must advise that we do not have any replacement units available for this product" and again stated they could only approve the original refund.
Crucial does clarify in the warranty section of its website, "We understand that replacement costs may be higher today. However, warranty coverage is tied to the original purchase."
An important point to note is that the Redditor buying this drive from Crucial last year meant they didn't buy one from a competitor. In getting a faulty drive, they missed out on getting a fresh one at the lower price they originally paid. Therefore, one would assume that Crucial should cover the replacement, as it sold a drive it believed would last longer than a single year.
Keep up to date with the most important stories and the best deals, as picked by the PC Gamer team.
When this problem was taken to Reddit, CarefulMeasurement99 was advised to inform Crucial "that a refund was unacceptable" and they "demanded a 4TB equivalent replacement (or alternative), and mentioned that this issue was gaining massive traction here on Reddit."
They also, on Reddit's advice, cited the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, which is an act that, among other things, tightened consumer remedies for active warranties. In this case, they seemingly threw in the reference to suggest that they would take some legal action if necessary.
Micron, being one of the big three memory manufacturers, certainly has the cash to spare, and it has profited heavily from the memory crisis that is causing the prices of memory to skyrocket.
Just a few hours after sending this email, Crucial approved a 1-to-1 replacement, confirming it had "limited inventory available to replace the drive with a new one".
Triumphantly returning to the subreddit, CarefulMeasurement99 said: "Holy shit, pushing back actually worked!"
1. Best overall: Adata SD810
2. Best budget: Crucial X9
3. Best for video editing: Samsung T9
4. Best USB4: Sandisk Extreme Pro
5. Best thumb drive replacement: Seagate Ultra Compact
6. Best durable drive: LaCie Rugged Pro 5
7. Best budget durable: Samsung T7 Shield
8. Best for backups: SanDisk Desk Drive
👉Check out our full external SSD guide👈
James is a more recent PC gaming convert, often admiring graphics cards, cases, and motherboards from afar. It was not until 2019, after just finishing a degree in law and media, that they decided to throw out the last few years of education, build their PC, and start writing about gaming instead. In that time, he has covered the latest doodads, contraptions, and gismos, and loved every ...Read more: Full article on www.pcgamer.com
What do you think about this?
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.
With the memory crisis only continuing to get worse, a PC gamer's fear right now is likely their memory, storage or GPU borking, and needing to spend an inflated price to replace it. One such Redditor had an external drive die in just one year, and Crucial only offered a refund of the original price they paid, which was a lot less than similar drives go for now. That was until they brought their problems to Reddit.
Over on the PCMR subreddit, user CarefulMeasurement99 shared that they bought a 4 TB Crucial drive a year ago for $200, and when it broke, Crucial offered that original price in a refund. That same drive seems to fetch up to $800 now (thanks, AI).
Crucial originally set up an RMA for the drive in order to pick it up and send it back to the company. The Redditor replied to this saying, "Due to the recent global increase in SSD prices, $199.999 is unfortunately no longer enough to purchase a new 4 TB drive in the current market", and officially requested a direct replacement.
This story gets a tad complicated because Micron announced the closure of the Crucial consumer business late last year, which threw its ability to actually replace the drive into question.
Crucial responded to this request saying, "after reviewing the current inventory situation, we must advise that we do not have any replacement units available for this product" and again stated they could only approve the original refund.
Crucial does clarify in the warranty section of its website, "We understand that replacement costs may be higher today. However, warranty coverage is tied to the original purchase."
An important point to note is that the Redditor buying this drive from Crucial last year meant they didn't buy one from a competitor. In getting a faulty drive, they missed out on getting a fresh one at the lower price they originally paid. Therefore, one would assume that Crucial should cover the replacement, as it sold a drive it believed would last longer than a single year.
Keep up to date with the most important stories and the best deals, as picked by the PC Gamer team.
When this problem was taken to Reddit, CarefulMeasurement99 was advised to inform Crucial "that a refund was unacceptable" and they "demanded a 4TB equivalent replacement (or alternative), and mentioned that this issue was gaining massive traction here on Reddit."
They also, on Reddit's advice, cited the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, which is an act that, among other things, tightened consumer remedies for active warranties. In this case, they seemingly threw in the reference to suggest that they would take some legal action if necessary.
Micron, being one of the big three memory manufacturers, certainly has the cash to spare, and it has profited heavily from the memory crisis that is causing the prices of memory to skyrocket.
Just a few hours after sending this email, Crucial approved a 1-to-1 replacement, confirming it had "limited inventory available to replace the drive with a new one".
Triumphantly returning to the subreddit, CarefulMeasurement99 said: "Holy shit, pushing back actually worked!"
1. Best overall: Adata SD810
2. Best budget: Crucial X9
3. Best for video editing: Samsung T9
4. Best USB4: Sandisk Extreme Pro
5. Best thumb drive replacement: Seagate Ultra Compact
6. Best durable drive: LaCie Rugged Pro 5
7. Best budget durable: Samsung T7 Shield
8. Best for backups: SanDisk Desk Drive
👉Check out our full external SSD guide👈
James is a more recent PC gaming convert, often admiring graphics cards, cases, and motherboards from afar. It was not until 2019, after just finishing a degree in law and media, that they decided to throw out the last few years of education, build their PC, and start writing about gaming instead. In that time, he has covered the latest doodads, contraptions, and gismos, and loved every ...Read more: Full article on www.pcgamer.com
What do you think about this?